29 Comments
User's avatar
Pete's avatar

This, I did not know.

"The old NAFTA contained an energy proportionality provision that limited Canada’s flexibility around energy exports.

That provision disappeared when NAFTA was replaced by CUSMA."

Wow, so Brian Mulroney signed the trade deal that limited Canada's energy exports. When one considers how Poilievre has whined like old gears about oil, this takes on new context.

CUSMA eliminated this provision. No wonder the red-hats are pissing mad about Canada accelerating energy exports to non US refineries.

Canada's sovereignty is not negotiable.

And that weird Jivani guy has some sort of relationship with JD Eyeliner, and apparently is trying to 'help'.

Thank goodness our negotiating team, and Prime Minister, are holding the line.

Now, it's our turn.

Make Boycotts Great Again.

Fred Ferguson (GeezerWise)'s avatar

Pete, that NAFTA provision surprised me too when I dug into it.

And you're right...

it puts today's energy-diversification argument into a much bigger historical context.

Whatever Canadians think about pipelines, oil or any particular government, there's a principle here that should cross party lines...

**Canada should decide where Canadian resources are sold. Period.**

That's why I think this moment is bigger than Trump.

We spent decades building an economy overwhelmingly pointed south.

Now we're finally discovering the price of having too few doors.

Build the ports.

Build the infrastructure.

Find more customers.

And I'll admit it…

**“Make Boycotts Great Again” gave this old geezer a chuckle. 😂🇨🇦**

Kevin 🇨🇦's avatar

You are right. But at that time Canada did not have any choice but to transport oil by pipeline to the US. We have more options now.

Fred Ferguson (GeezerWise)'s avatar

Exactly, Kevin.

That's an important distinction.

For much of our history, geography and infrastructure made the U.S. the obvious...

and often only practical...

destination for enormous amounts of Canadian energy.

**The mistake would be acting as though that still has to be our only choice.**

We have Pacific access through Trans Mountain now...

and we're finally talking seriously about more ports, pipelines, LNG and trade infrastructure serving other markets.

I'm not interested in blaming Canada for the decisions that made sense 30 years ago.

I'm interested in making damn sure **we have more choices 30 years from now.**

Gordon Bullivant's avatar

Trump’s Administration has destroyed our friendship. Absolutely appalling

Fred Ferguson (GeezerWise)'s avatar

I hear you, Gordon.

That's the part I find hardest to watch.

This was never just a trading relationship.

Canadians and Americans have been neighbours, friends, allies and family across that border for generations.

Governments can eventually repair trade agreements.

**Trust is a hell of a lot harder to rebuild.**

And I don't blame ordinary Americans for what their government is doing.

A great many of them are watching this mess with the same disbelief we are.

Someday Trump will be gone.

**Canada and America will still be neighbours...

I hope we remember that when it's time to repair what he's damaged.**

Jerry's avatar

I refuse to call it "Trump's Administration". Shouldn't it be described as "Trump's Regime"?

It's a regime filled with boot-licking, butt-kissing sycophants. Billionaires and maybe one trillionaire who feel that they don't have enough wealth. Led by a totally corrupt, convicted felon, demented, 80-year old self-proclaimed "stable genius" who by many accounts is insane. So, "regime" is my description of choice.

His Republican Senators and Congressmen/Congresswomen are complicit because too many of them are enablers and lackeys of Trump.

Having said this, I know from our previous travels south in our little camper van, there are many good people in the US. Once Trump was elected, all our trips to the US stopped.

But one thing nags me a lot: after January 6, how could Trump possibly be elected once again?

And yes, there WAS a friendship, but it's going to take many years to repair, perhaps a generation or two.

Fred Ferguson (GeezerWise)'s avatar

Jerry, that last question is the one historians are going to wrestle with for a very long time.

After January 6, after everything Americans had already seen, **how did enough voters decide to hand him the keys again?**

And I agree with your other important point...

we shouldn't confuse the American government with the American people.

I've met too many decent Americans to do that.

But something fundamental has changed for me too.

I no longer believe Canada can build its future on the assumption that the United States will always be the predictable friend we grew up beside.

Trump will eventually be gone.

Geography won't be.

So we'll remain neighbours, and hopefully friends again.

**But Canada should never again confuse friendship with dependence.**

Grant Rowson's avatar

How could he be re-elected again, after Jan 6? Answer: Because about 30% of Americans actually think he's doing everything right, and can do no wrong.

So this is one of the things where I do have slight disagreement with Fred (and others): The current mess is NOT just Trump and his Regime. 30% of Americans are also behind it. The whole adage of "well, once we remove Trump from office, everything will be better" got disproved with the Biden election. What should have been something like 60% or 70% democrats, only had 50% percent or so voting for Biden, and Trump's forces were still in Congress doing everything they could to set the stage for the "great second coming."

So until they (meaning the other 70%) figure out what to do with their "30% problem", this whole pattern will continue to be one election away from today's bedlam.

I've known many Americans who were good people, too. But not all of them are . . . . (30%).

So now, I converge back into agreement with Fred: We can't have friendship/dependence again, at least not how it's been for the past 100+ years. We can have friends there, but we can't depend on the country, as a whole.

Fred Ferguson (GeezerWise)'s avatar

Grant, I don't think we're very far apart on this one.

I'll stay away from putting an exact percentage on it without tying that number to a specific poll,

but your larger point lands with me.

**Trump didn't create all of this by himself.**

There is a substantial political movement behind him, voters who support it, politicians who enable it,

and an infrastructure that survived his first departure from office.

And that's the lesson Canada cannot afford to forget.

Someday Trump will be gone.

We may get another American president who genuinely wants to repair the relationship.

I hope we do.

But Canada cannot rebuild the old dependency on the assumption that the next Trump... or something resembling him... won't arrive four years later.

We can have American friends.

We can trade heavily with America.

We can cooperate on defence, energy and everything else that makes sense.

**But friendship and dependence are two very different things.**

On that, Grant, I think we've landed on exactly the same square.

Gordon Bullivant's avatar

A Fascist one!

Cat JB's avatar

That was an annexation agreement and im furious. And why is canadian news reporting what the US regime is saying without corrections

Fred Ferguson (GeezerWise)'s avatar

Cat, I understand why you're furious.

I wouldn't literally call the document an “annexation agreement” because we haven't seen enough of the proposed text to prove that.

But when another country wants a say over **who Canada can make future trade agreements with**, Carney was right to call it a sovereignty issue.

And on the media... I actually want Canadian journalists reporting what the Americans are saying.

**But don't stop there.**

Tell us what Washington claims.

Then tell us what Ottawa claims.

Then dig into the evidence, explain what the disputed terms actually mean, and tell Canadians what can and cannot be verified.

Repeating a government statement isn't journalism's final job.

**It's where the journalism is supposed to start.**

Pete's avatar

I expect more from Canadian news, and we've debated the US ownership of our news distribution and publishing to the point where it feels like screaming in the wind. You ARE spot on, and we need to make biased reporting unpopular, and unprofitable. Therein lies the foundation of non controlled media, and private contributors.

Susan's avatar

This is so, so annoying and it has been going on for a long time.

They know they are reporting Trump's lies.

There is no excuse for this.

Kevin 🇨🇦's avatar

Thanks Fred. Thoughtful and clearly stated as always.

Chezzie's avatar

No, AMERICA - more specifically the United States - did not ask too much. The bloated orange racist pedophile demented buffoon PoS tearing down the white house did. And he didn't ask. He tried to be sneaky because he thinks he's the smartest person in the room. But he's not, and I am sincerely thankful that Mr. Carney told him to go jump in a lake. It's time somebody did.

Fred Ferguson (GeezerWise)'s avatar

Chezzie, I'll give you an important correction to my headline...

**America is not Donald Trump.**

There are millions of Americans who didn't ask for any of this, don't support what their government is doing,

and probably want their Canadian neighbour back as much as we eventually want our American neighbour back.

Where I'm completely with you is the important part...

Canada reached its line.

Carney didn't accept the deal simply because Washington expected Canada eventually would.

He got up from the table.

And I suspect that surprised some people who had become convinced Canadians would ultimately swallow whatever was put in front of us.

**Not this time. **

Kyle Alan Lencucha 🇨🇦's avatar

I think the only question I’m left with after this is how we’re going to fill the gaps left by walking away

I know we’re making deals with Europe and Asia but thinking more closer to home it wouldn’t be a bad idea to try and fill any gaps left by expanding trade further with Mexico in any way we need to

Then again I’m a dunce when it comes to trade policy so it’s not like I even know if that’s possible or not

Fred Ferguson (GeezerWise)'s avatar

Kyle, don't sell yourself short...

that's exactly the question Canadians should be asking now.

Mexico absolutely belongs in this conversation.

We're already CUSMA partners, and there are plenty of areas where stronger Canada-Mexico trade and investment could make sense.

But I don't think we're going to replace one giant American customer with another giant customer somewhere else.

**The whole point is not needing one.**

Mexico.

Europe.

Asia.

The UK. Indo-Pacific markets.

And a hell of a lot more trade between Canadian provinces while we're at it.

Some American trade will remain because geography makes it sensible.

What Canada needs to eliminate isn't trade with America.

**It's dependence on America.**

Grant Rowson's avatar

Canada and Mexico have spent the past year, somewhat quietly, forging closer relations between the two countries (including direct supply of agricultural products between us, without the "middleman"). And Mexico sent firefighters to help us this season.

And there are efforts with both countries to develop various Pacific trade blocs, with Mercosur, and with Europe. So it's happening -- but it does take time for everything to come together.

Fred Ferguson (GeezerWise)'s avatar

Exactly, Grant. And that's the encouraging part.

We're talking about diversification as though Canada has to start doing it tomorrow, when quite a bit of the groundwork is already underway.

Mexico especially interests me because they're not some theoretical future trading partner.

They're already our CUSMA partner and we're actively building a much broader relationship with them.

Then add Europe, the Pacific, Mercosur and the other relationships Canada is developing.

But you've nailed the frustrating part...

**It takes time.**

You can sign an agreement relatively quickly.

You can't instantly build ports, railways, pipelines, supply chains and decades of business relationships.

Which is another reason I'm glad we're starting now.

**The Canada we're building isn't about replacing the United States with another dependency.

It's about finally having choices.**

Pete's avatar

You're asking a very important question. No dunce granted. We all are attempting to read pages and chapters ahead of where the country goes.

Fred Ferguson (GeezerWise)'s avatar

Exactly, Pete.

That's where I am too.

Nobody has the next chapters in front of them.

We're watching Canada make decisions today that could shape the country for decades.

That's why I love questions like Kyle's.

We don't need to pretend we have all the answers.

**We need Canadians asking the right questions, comparing what we know, and thinking a few moves ahead.**

That's half the reason I write this stuff.

And increasingly...

the smartest part of the article shows up down here in the comments.

Rebecca's avatar

My feelings,

It’s bigger than trade.

It’s about morality.

It’s about what happens when a nation with extraordinary power begins to lose its moral compass—and the rest of the world decides whether to look away.

We are watching the headlines unfold: the Epstein files, the scandals, the convictions, the cruelty, the attacks on institutions, the treatment of immigrants, the wars and threats, the tariffs, the rhetoric that turns neighbours into enemies and compassion into weakness.

And perhaps the most disturbing part is not any single event.

It is the normalization of it.

History has a way of whispering before it begins to shout.

It reminds us that authoritarianism rarely arrives wearing a sign that says authoritarianism.

It arrives wrapped in nationalism.

It speaks of greatness.

It promises to restore what was supposedly stolen.

It tells people that their problems are caused by them—the immigrant, the outsider, the enemy, the neighbour.

It slowly teaches a society that cruelty is strength, that obedience is patriotism, and that questioning power is somehow betrayal.

We should recognize those echoes—not because history repeats itself perfectly, but because human beings do.

And we should be especially concerned when those echoes are coming from the leader of a nuclear superpower.

This is why Canada’s response cannot simply be reduced to tariffs, trade agreements or economic retaliation.

Something deeper is happening.

We are being asked what kind of country we want to be.

For generations, Canada has been the country willing to compromise. Willing to cooperate. Willing to say, Let’s find a way through this.

And we still are.

But there comes a moment when getting along begins to require giving something fundamental away.

Our sovereignty.

Our principles.

Our humanity.

And that is where we draw the line.

Because being Canadian isn’t simply about the maple leaf on our flag.

It is about the values beneath it.

Compassion.

Decency.

Dignity.

Inclusion.

Respect for human life.

The belief that strength does not require humiliation, that leadership does not require cruelty, and that our neighbour’s suffering does not make our own lives more secure.

So perhaps this moment is bigger than a trade war.

Perhaps it is a declaration.

Not against the American people.

Not against our American neighbours, our families, or our friends.

But for ourselves.

A declaration that Canada will not measure its worth by how closely it can stand beside power.

We will measure it by how faithfully we stand beside humanity.

We can be peaceful without being passive.

We can be compassionate without being weak.

We can be a good neighbour without surrendering our identity.

And we can say, with both humility and conviction:

We don’t want to be the most powerful country in the room.

We simply want to remain a decent one.

Because when history asks what we did when power began to forget morality, I want Canada to have an answer.

We remembered who we were

Fred Ferguson (GeezerWise)'s avatar

Rebecca, I had to read this twice.

You took my argument somewhere bigger than trade, and I think there's something very important in what you've written.

Countries ultimately have to decide not only what they're willing to pay for prosperity, but **what they're unwilling to become to obtain it.**

Canada isn't perfect.

We've got plenty in our own history to answer for, and we'll make plenty more mistakes.

But I want the country you're describing.

Strong enough to defend itself.

Independent enough to make its own decisions.

Decent enough not to mistake cruelty for strength.

And this line deserves repeating...

**“We don’t want to be the most powerful country in the room. We simply want to remain a decent one.”**

Beautifully said, Rebecca.

Sometimes I write the article and one of you folks finishes it for me.

Gordon Bullivant's avatar

Agreed. Centuries of good will gone

Fred Ferguson (GeezerWise)'s avatar

Yes, Gordon.

And that's what makes this so damn sad.

We weren't just countries that traded with each other.

We built continental defence together, fought alongside each other, raised families across that border and spent generations assuming the friendship would still be there tomorrow.

I don't think all of that goodwill is permanently gone.

But **trust has been badly damaged...

and whoever eventually tries to rebuild it is going to discover...

trust takes a hell of a lot longer to restore than it does to destroy.**