36 Comments
User's avatar
Arctic Fox's avatar

I commented on an item you did some months back about this.

This is the same modus and (probably) the same players as Brexit.

As a Brit who watched his country (from Europe while working there) taken over by frauds, charlatans, spivs and grifters who took the country out of the EU using an advisory referendum as a vehicle - I really must urge you all to WAKE UP.

You can see the direction of travel taken in the UK since and the absolute disaster that we now face. You have also seen the way the US will behave when one of the herd strays. To paraphrase your PM - and our former Bank of England manager - if you aren’t surrounded by your herd you will succumb to the wolves.

Fred Ferguson (GeezerWise)'s avatar

That's a powerful warning from someone who lived through Brexit.

The parallel that concerns me is how a referendum can deepen divisions long before anyone understands the full consequences.

Alberta deserves a serious discussion about what separation would actually mean, including treaty rights, trade and its relationship with the rest of Canada.

Thanks for bringing that firsthand perspective to the conversation.

Arctic Fox's avatar

The divisions were the point IMO.

What people didn’t understand was the balance changed by leaving but they had been led to believe nothing would change.

The perpetrators said the EU were punishing them for leaving and those that swallowed the leave narrative followed the punishing line.

This travesty cost a lot of us living in the EU an immeasurable amount of harm - we weren’t punished by the EU we were rescued in most cases.

I was trapped by the agreement Johnson chose which left us out of the NHS if we weren’t resident in UK. You needed to buy travel insurance to have medical cover for anything other than emergency treatment. So for a British Citizen to go home to the land they had contributed to health insurance for over 50 years was told that was now worthless.

I have a pre-existing condition so could not get travel insurance that would cover me.

My wife is German and although she lived and worked in the UK for 40 years she could not have settled status so we were not able to move back - if we wanted to!

I truly hope you do not sleepwalk into this nightmare.

Cfontani's avatar

Our First Nations brothers and sisters are the original settlers of this great country. Everyone else are immigrants.

Those who want to separate from this country should return to their country of origin. Revoke their Canadian citizenship, cancel their driver’s and business licenses, withdraw their OAS benefits, return their CPP contributions, and delist their SIN.

Fred Ferguson (GeezerWise)'s avatar

I agree that First Nations rights must be respected, and they've been largely overlooked in this debate.

But I wouldn't strip anyone of citizenship or benefits for supporting separation.

Canadians have the right to disagree, even about Confederation.

My concern is making sure a relatively small political movement doesn't speak for an entire province without the people understanding the consequences.

RoyP's avatar

Thank you for a well written and researched article.

Fred Ferguson (GeezerWise)'s avatar

Thanks, Roy. I appreciate that.

This investigation taught me a few things I didn't know, even after spending more than 30 years in Alberta.

Always something new to learn!

Patsy Rideout's avatar

Thank you Fred, another thought provoking issue. We need the whitehouse trips to stay out of our politics, however, it may be too late for that! I/we don't need our country turning into the mess next door!!! Little kids being grabbed & held by ICE as they came out of school, a 5 year old watching his Dad getting shot! The leader should have been in jail long ago for starting this mess! He knows exactly what he is doing, no matter how many times he falls asleep, he is still harming children, as well as adults!!! Do we want this mess in Canada? No!!!!!!!!!!! Vote DS out of her position before it is too late!

Sheryl Campbell's avatar

Agree 1000% - Smith needs to get on her high horse and ride away from Alberta permanently.

Fred Ferguson (GeezerWise)'s avatar

Thanks, Patsy. I understand your concern. The last thing Canada needs is outside interference in our political decisions. Albertans have every right to debate their future, but that debate belongs to Albertans and Canadians, not Washington. And we certainly don't need to import America's political chaos along with its tariffs!

Juliette Reynolds's avatar

This all sounds horribly familiar to Global Geopolitical Researchers, Fred.

Which country benefitted from wrenching the UK out of the European Union when its combined economy looked likely to surpass its own?

Which country benefits from the forced deindustrialisation of Germany, Europe's economic powerhouse and third richest economy in the world by GDP?

Which country likely caused a regime change in Japan (the fourth richest economy in the world by GDP), arguably its "useful puppet in Asia" against its primary rival and second richest economy in the world by GDP, China?

Which country is inciting a youth-led "Cockroach Revolution" in India, now the fifth richest economy in the world by GDP?

Which country would benefit from the potential break up of the United Kingdom, the sixth richest economy in the world by GDP?

Which country is inciting youth-led riots in France, the seventh richest economy in the world by GDP?

Which country may have had a hand in influencing the outcomes of elections in Italy, the 8th and Brazil, the 9th richest economies in the world by GDP?

Guess who's next on the list? https://usdebtclock.org/world-debt-clock.html

BTW, Canada is actually 11th because carefully disguised in this US chart is the fact that (contrary to popular belief) Russia's economy has climbed back up to surpass that of Italy and is once again the 8th richest economy in the world, despite 4.5 years of war with Ukraine and the mysterious loss of the Nord Stream pipeline which supplied cheap gas to most of Western Europe, forcing us all to import expensively shipped LPG at highly inflated prices from "our friends across the pond".

I could continue with speculating who is behind ongoing problems in Spain, South Korea, Mexico, Australia, Turkiye, etc ...

Or simply ask, "Which country has always maintained it "MUST BE NUMBER ONE"?

Fred Ferguson (GeezerWise)'s avatar

Juliette, you've raised some big geopolitical questions here.

Foreign influence is certainly something Canadians need to take seriously, especially when our sovereignty is involved.

But I'd want solid evidence before attributing all those international events to one country's interference.

What concerns me most about Alberta is what we can actually document... the political organizing, the referendum process, and the reported Washington meetings.

There's enough there to warrant serious questions without having to speculate.

Thanks for adding your perspective.

Frank Kuma's avatar

Fred, it will take some stand up leadership to withstand the evil from within. The GOP has worked a minority position for years to their advantage in the US. Alberta has to be on its toes and don't be shy to arrest the treasonous dissidents.

Fred Ferguson (GeezerWise)'s avatar

Thanks, Frank.

I understand the concern, but supporting separation isn't treason.

People have the right to advocate for constitutional change, even when we strongly disagree with them.

Foreign interference or actual criminal activity is another matter, and that's where evidence and the law must come first.

We defend democracy by protecting it, not by arresting people for their political opinions.

Sandi J Horton's avatar

This morning I heard an interview with Mr. Sylvestre on CBC. He in fact stated that if the Separatists don't get between 40-65% of the votes in the referendum that he will suspect foul play in the counting process. And would blame mail in voting. He made other comments about not accepting the results and that the movement would press on, getting their people elected into the Legislature and so on. But if they did in fact achieve the amounts stated above then he would trust mail in voting.

I hope things go the other way obviously but the next election needs to be a thorough trouncing of these separatist leanings and learning to work with our Federal Government to achieve good things for Alberta and Canada.

Fred Ferguson (GeezerWise)'s avatar

Thanks, Sandi.

That's concerning if Sylvestre said that.

Questioning the integrity of an election before the votes are even counted is a serious matter.

If there are legitimate concerns, they deserve evidence and proper investigation.

But accepting the results only when they go your way isn't how democracy works.

I'll have to look up that CBC interview.

Jerry's avatar

I live in Ontario but have relatives in Calgary, Edmonton, Vegreville, and Viking. There's something about Danielle Smith that has never sat right with me. I don't take her statement about wanting Alberta to remain in Canada at face value. Too little, too late. I believe that she's still the Mar-A-Largo wannabee that she's always been. Her role in encouraging the separatists in the UCP so as not to lose any votes to the opposition NDP is well noted. The voters in Calgary-Shaw point to her duplicity.

Sandi J Horton's avatar

I agree with you regarding Danielle Smith. I have felt ever since she was chosen to be head of UCP that we've seen a person who speaks with a forked tongue and admired TFG and the US administration immensely. When she gets voted out, I hope she leaves Canada and joins her buddies in America.

Fred Ferguson (GeezerWise)'s avatar

Thanks, Sandi.

I can understand why people question Smith's position.

She says she wants Alberta to remain in Canada, but her government's actions have left plenty of people wondering where she really stands.

I'd rather judge her by what she does than speculate about where she'd like to live.

And right now, there's plenty to examine.

Fred Ferguson (GeezerWise)'s avatar

Thanks, Jerry.

I think the important distinction is between what Smith says and what her government has actually done.

She says she supports keeping Alberta in Canada, but she's also opened the door to this referendum process.

It's fair to question that contradiction without pretending we know her private intentions.

The CBC investigation certainly gave me plenty to think about.

Marcel Desjardins's avatar

Same situation has happenned twice in province of Québec and with the now Newly elected Parti Quebecois in Power this past élection.. Quebecers will be asked to vote on a 3rd référendum in the next 3 years if the NEW premier PSPP gets is way in the Québec House of commons before 203..

The first Québec référendum in 1980 was lost by séparatist Parti Quebecois 60%NO to 40%Yeah ....3nd attempt in 1995 référendum by same party also ended up loosing by 51%NO and 49% Yeah for séparation of Québec from Canada's fédération... NOW; Quebecers will be forced to vote again by référendum before the end of 2030 if Newly elected Premier, Pierre St-Paul Plamondon (PSPP) Leader of Parti Quebecois gets is way....

Here we GO Again🙄 !! .... The real DANGER is how Americans react to a weaken Canadian Federal Government; if Alberta gets their wish and also the Province of QUEBEC to start négociations to separate from the COMMONWEALTH of CANADA ... 🙄🤔🙄😐 !!!

Scary times are among us in Canada with the Americans wishing to make Canada it's 51st State...POLITICAL LOBBYING in Canada in récent decades have become hazardous to Canada’s SOVEREIGNTY and NOT necessarily Président TRUMP . 🙄😱 !

Fred Ferguson (GeezerWise)'s avatar

Marcel, Quebec has certainly taught Canada how divisive referendums can be, especially after that razor-thin 1995 result.

One correction though... the PQ hasn't formed a new government, and PSPP isn't premier.

A third referendum remains a possibility, not a certainty.

Your larger concern is worth discussing.

With Canada already facing pressure from Washington, simultaneous unity debates in Alberta and Quebec would raise some very serious questions about our future.

Bonny Byzuk's avatar

CBC!!?? ARE You kidding?? They are best liars paid by communist government in canada!!

Fred Ferguson (GeezerWise)'s avatar

Frank and Bonny, I appreciate how you handled this.

You disagreed, things got personal, an apology was offered and accepted.

That's how adults settle differences.

Strong opinions are welcome here, including opinions I disagree with.

Personal insults aren't.

We can argue about politics without attacking each other.

Thanks to both of you.

Frank Kuma's avatar

Hey Bonny, will Trump's government pay for your facial reconstruction after the meth burns a hole through the roof of your mouth? You'd be better off staying in Canada.

Fred Ferguson (GeezerWise)'s avatar

Frank and Bonny, I appreciate how you handled this.

You disagreed, things got personal, an apology was offered and accepted.

That's how adults settle differences.

Strong opinions are welcome here, including opinions I disagree with.

Personal insults aren't.

We can argue about politics without attacking each other.

Thanks to both of you.

Bonny Byzuk's avatar

Frank! I'm 77. No meth smoking, or whatever they do with those drugs. Don't even drink, or smoke anything!! But, you, you need help..be sane when making any comment, & have some facts. Here's another, I am not a game player.

Frank Kuma's avatar

Hello Bonny, although I totally oppose your support for Alberta separation, my meth joke was out of line and for that I do apologize.

Bonny Byzuk's avatar

Thank you Frank!! I'm an adult too. You even had a point or two..I believe in free speech, and welcome ideas and comments on both sides!! You're a real man, Frank!!

Harry's avatar

Hey Bonny I think the meth has fried what little brain you had. Better back off.

Estella  de Souza's avatar

Alberta’s betrayal of Canada and its people

The View from my Window's avatar

With all the questions on the ballot it's a pick and chose no mater what the main question is. They are all cryptic for a reason to cover everything no mater what the results. IMHO no mater what Alberta will be the loser in all this. A no vote and movement on one of the other 9 will isolate Alberta from the rest of Canada. A yes vote and the result is the same.

Marcel Desjardins's avatar

Ido beleive Fred that POLITICAL LOBBYING is becoming more prevelent and is corrupting our POLITICAL system to our dismay..

You should write and investigate on The “dozen secret loopholes” in Canada’s federal lobbying law

(April 2025)

Published by:

"TheDemocracywatch.ca"

Independant advocacy group surveying LOBBYIST firms and group in Canada. 🤔😐⚠️

Publishing this interesting piece,

On the Federal Lobbying Act and Rules contain a “dirty dozen” loopholes that allow for covert lobbying. None of the following significant lobbying activities need to be recorded and disclosed. 😮🙊🙉🙈⚠️

I stongly beleive more and more of lobbying is present politically under our noses without any disclosure to the general public being promoted . 🤔😏 !

Marcel,

Marcel Desjardins's avatar

For your info Fred, PSPP of Parti Quebecois is to be sworn in this coming Thursday as the NEW Premier of Quebec winning the élection of Octobre 5th, and one of his top 3 priorities once Premier of Québec is to get support from Québec Solidaire party whom are also in favor of séparation for Québec. That would GIVE his minority party a go FORWARD to obtain that 3rd référendum in Québec to Go ahead for negotiating separation procedures from Canada.

The political calendar of 2026 increases the risk that constitutional and jurisdictional disputes will move from background noise to major points of contention. A potential looming federal election, an election in Québec, won to a minority Government by Parti Quebecois seeking a 3rd référendum on séparation and ongoing political battles in Alberta and British Columbia over energy policy, climate targets, and revenue sharing all create incentives for political and lobbyist LEADERS to campaign against Ottawa or other provinces. This “politics of perpetual grievance” erodes the trust necessary for joint economic projects. Without further signs of progress, the summer’s “elbow bump” risks turning into an atmosphere of declining confidence by Winter 2027 according from a Financial report forwarded by RBC Financial experts in Canada.

Also, LOBBYIST in Canada gain momentum via:

• Disproportionate Wealth: Large corporations and industry groups possess massive budgets, allowing them to secure greater and more sophisticated access to politicians than average citizens.

• The "Revolving Door": Former politicians and high-ranking public servants frequently become lobbyist firms' top assets, capitalizing on their personal networks once their legal blackout period expires.

• Shadow Lobbying: Despite a strict registry maintained by the Office of the Commissioner of Lobbying, informal interactions or loopholes can sometimes shield significant policy discussions from public view.

LOBBYIST firms in Canada are to my view, more dangerous to our préservation of Canadian Sovereignty than the Americans wanting to make Canada their 51st State. 😏😐🙄 !

Bonny Byzuk's avatar

You're welcome!! Yes, even in the heat of campaign mode, being civilized is the way to go!!! I love debate, but I enjoy being an adult too!!